Thomas Haigh Dissertation TOC

Home
About Me
Writing
Teaching
Research
Vita
Contact

1. INTRODUCTION 1

Continuity Amid Revolution 4

Narrative Summary 11

Computers and the Corporation 18

Technicians and Management 24

Sources of Managerial Legitimacy: Systems, Science, and Information 33

Institutions, Occupations, and Identities 39

Managers and Professionals 45

Axes of Identity 49

SECTION I: EXPERTS AND MACHINES IN CORPORATE ADMINISTRATION, 1917-1958 58

2. ENGINEERING THE PROGRESSIVE OFFICE, 1917-1940 58

Scientific Office Management 60

The Office Management Movement 67

Technology and Office Management 71

Management and Technology in Practice 79

Bookkeeping Machinery and Managerial Systematization 83

Dictating Inefficiency 89

The Fate of Systematic Office Management 94

Leffingwell’s Legacy 97

3. SYSTEM MEN AND MANAGEMENT SCIENTISTS 102

Management in the 1950s 102

The Systems Men 109

Tensions of Line and Staff 114

Generalists, Specialists, and Professionals 125

Drawing the Boundaries – What Systems Work Wasn’t 131

Systems Work In Practice 136

Operations Research in the 1950s 140

4. SORTING PUNCHED CARDS AND SHIFTING IDENTITIES: THE “MACHINE MEN” BETTER THEMSELVES 152

From Hollerith to Machine Accounting 154

Life in the Tab Room 161

Becoming Machine Accountants 174

How To Better Oneself – Machine Accounting and Systems 181

Blue Piping, White Collars 184

Inside The NMAA 188

Three Visions of Management 193

SECTION II: CREATING DATA PROCESSING 1954-1958 197

5. BUYING AND SELLING AN ELECTRONIC REVOLUTION 197

“The Ominous Rumble You Sense is the Future Coming At Us” 206

“The Machine Accountant and His Electronic Opportunity” 208

“High-Speed Operations Research for High-Speed Business” 216

“A Dream off A Pink Cloud”: Selling a Revolution 221

…Buying a Computer 228

Pushing for Status 239

Doing the Same Things, Faster 247

6. BUILDING THE DATA PROCESSING DEPARTMENT 253

Punched Card Machines + Computers = Data Processing 262

Operating The Computer 267

The Shock of the New Furniture 280

Systems Analysis and Flowcharting 285

Programming – The New Task 291

The Craft of Programming 301

SECTION III: FROM DATA TO INFORMATION 1959-1975 320

7. DATA PROCESSING EVOLVES 320

The Second Generation Machines 325

Applications, Staffing and Practice 332

COBOL: “A Step In the Right Direction” 341

On-Line Systems and Random-Access Storage 357

The Third Generation 369

Operators and Operating Systems 374

The Third Generation In Practice 385

8. INVENTING MANAGEMENT INFORMATION 392

Information and Management 395

The Totally Integrated Management Information System 409

The Origins of Totality 414

“Two Paths Diverge”: The Systems Men and the Computer 428

Uniting Systems, Operations Research and Data Processing 441

Selling MIS and the Third Generation 446

Failure as a Cultural Resource 453

The Information Pyramid: A Challenge to the Controller 456

The Fate of MIS 463

MIS in the 1970s and Beyond 471

9. THE DATA PROCESSING DEPARTMENT IN THE 1970S 491

“EDP: The Twenty Year Rip-Off?” 494

Climbing the Ladder 499

The Computer Department as an Efficient Factory 508

Decentralization, Time-sharing, and the Minicomputer 516

The Arrival of Packaged Software 525

The Death of the Programmer Was Much Exaggerated 534

SECTION IV: PROFESSIONALISM IN ADMINISTRATIVE COMPUTING, 1959-1975 544

10. DATA PROCESSING AS PROFESSIONAL IDENTITY 544

“Ride the Fad into the Land of the Walnut Desk” 547

“Three Parts Office Manager to One Part Mr. Einstein”: Office Management in the Electronic Era 549

Machine Accounting to Data Processing 558

Building a Profession Through Education 561

A New Certificate Is Born 567

The CDP In Practice 574

Members of the DPMA 585

DPMA Chapters versus DPMA Headquarters 590

The CDP and the Profession 598

11. PAN-COMPUTER PROFESSIONALISM: DATA PROCESSING MEETS COMPUTING 611

Computing vs. Data Processing 612

Pan-computer Professionalism Defined 622

RAND, Los Angeles, and the Origins of Pan-computer Professionalism 631

SIGBDP: The ACM Discovers Data Processing 640

“Would You Want Your Sister To Marry One?” Computing Flirts with Data Processing 645

Certification and Pan-Computer Professionalism 663

How To Not Join AFIPS 668

12. DATA PROCESSING PROFESSIONALISM IN CRISIS 679

The DPMA in the Late 1960s 680

Crisis 1: The Failure of Managerial Professionalism 682

Crisis 2: The Expansion of Certification 689

Crisis 3: Dwindling Membership 695

Rethinking Certification 700

The 1970s: A Partial Rapprochement 707

The Fall of Elliot 713

The DPMA in AFIPS and the ICCP 716

Pan-computer Professionalism In Retrospect 725

SECTION V: BEYOND DATA PROCESSING, 1975-2000 735

13. NEW TECHNOLOGIES AND NEW IDENTITIES 735

Software Engineering 737

The Data Base and the Data Resource Function 753

Office Automation 766

The Personal Computer and End User Computing 774

14. THE CHIEF INFORMATION OFFICER IN THEORY AND PRACTICE 787

The Information Executive for the Information Age 789

The Spread of the CIO Concept 799

The CIO in Practice 806

Total Systems Return: BRP, ERP, CRM 813

Changes in the Corporate Computing Workforce 823

The CIO and the Internet 835

The Two Cultures of Corporate Computing 841

Beyond Information 845

15. CONCLUSIONS AND FURTHER RESEARCH 855

Continuity and Change for the Managerial Technician 855

Further Research 864

Information and the Historian 869

APPENDIX: TIMELINE 875

BIBLIOGRAPHY 908


Page copyright Thomas Haigh -- email thaigh@computer.org    Home: www.tomandmaria.com/tom. Updated 12/11/2009.